Asian Healthcare Specialists
  • Home
  • Our Services
    • Dermatology
    • ENT
    • Gastroenterology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Orthopaedic
    • Urology
    • Family Medicine
    • Anaesthesia
  • About Us
    • Our Specialists
    • Careers
  • Our Clinics
  • Newsroom
  • Medical Insights
  • Contact Us
    • Medical Enquiry
    • Corporate Enquiry
    • Book an Appointment
    • Consult Our Specialists
BOOK AN APPOINTMENT
mainadmin2025-02-24T14:32:41+08:00
  • Home
  • Newsroom
  • Mini Mid-Vastus Approach Shows Similar Radiographic Results To Standard TKA

Mini Mid-Vastus Approach Shows Similar Radiographic Results To Standard TKA

February 25, 2014
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google + Email
Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA)

Some surgeons are questioning the viability of implant alignment for mini total knee arthroplasty involving side cuts.

While a recent randomized controlled trial found similar results with standard and mini mid-vastus techniques, researchers discovered inferior radiographic outcomes with mini side-cutting procedures.

Singaporean researchers compared 90 consecutive total knee arthroplasty (TKA) patients allocated to the following three treatment groups: standard TKA (using a medial parapatellar reconstruction), mini mid-vastus, and minimally invasive side-cutting arthroplasty. They found good outcomes in 83.3% of patients in both the standard and mini mid-vastus groups, yet they discovered similar results in only 56.7% of the side-cutting cohort (P=.024).

“We found that the mini mid-vastus technique gave us parallel results to the traditional method of the medial parapatella approach,” said Leon S.S. Foo, MD, an orthopaedist at Singapore General Hospital. “However, this was not the case in the side-cutting technique.”

In the minimally invasive surgery (MIS) groups, Foo and his colleagues found better component alignment in the tibia compared to the femur.

“Even comparing these two MIS techniques, side cuts had poorer outcomes,” Foo said. Investigators noted good tibial alignment in 90% of the mini mid-vastus group vs. 76.7% of side-cut patients. Similarly, 80% of mini mid-vastus patients had good femoral alignment compared to 66.7% of the side-cut group.

 

Matched Groups

“We also found that with the current instrumentation, the cutting jig-to-bone fixation is inadequate.”Leon S.S. Foo, MD

The study included osteoarthritis patients undergoing TKA and excluded those with previous knee surgery and genus valgus. The investigators obtained hospital ethics committee approval for the trial, and all patients gave informed consent, Foo said.

The researchers allocated patients using a randomization table created by an independent statistician. Each group contained 30 patients with similar demographics. All patients, research assistants, physiotherapists and statisticians were blinded to patient allocation.

Patient allocation was done by sealed envelopes, which were opened by the performing surgeons prior to surgery. “All surgeries were performed by two surgeons, each of whom had performed at least 200 total knee surgeries in the past year,” Foo said.

 

Complications

Postoperatively, two patients in the standard cohort developed deep vein thrombosis. One mini mid-vastus patient had postoperative knee stiffness, which resolved with manipulation and anesthesia. Similarly, one patient in the side-cutting group had postoperative knee stiffness and another developed a superficial wound infection.

The investigators took postop radiographs when patients could stand without flexion. They used seven angles described in a study by P.L. Chin and colleagues to calculate component placement.

“[Angles] A and B looked at bone cuts, C and D looked at the soft tissue balancing and angle E was the most important, looking at the mechanical axis of the lower limb,” Foo said. Angle F noted the flexion angle of the femoral component, while angle T measured the posterior slope of the tibial component.

 

Defining Good Outcome

“We defined good outcomes for the alignment of femoral and the tibial components as ± 3° of 0° for angles A-E, 0°— 5° for the angle of the femoral component and 0°—7° for the posterior slope of the tibial component,” he said.

Foo and his colleagues found better component alignment in the tibia compared to the femur.

They found a mean of 1.03° varus in the standard knee group, while the mini mid-vastus and side-cut cohorts showed 0.87° and 0.37° of varus, respectively.

According to the researchers’ criteria for good outcomes, 25 patients in both the standard and mini mid-vastus groups showed adequate alignment. Only 17 patients in the side-cutting cohort had similar results.

“We also found that with both MIS techniques, there was better component alignment in the tibia compared to the femur,” Foo said. Of these groups, fewer patients in the side-cutting group had good outcomes when researchers separately examined the tibial and femoral component alignment.

 

Recommendations

Foo pointed to the “intrinsic problems” of the side-cutting technique to explain the group’s results.

“The saw blade transverses a longer bone cut distance, and any cutting jig-to-bone errors [were] magnified,” he said. “We also found that with the current instrumentation, the cutting jig-to-bone fixation is inadequate.”

Foo also cited the procedure’s limited line of sight and decreased surgical window as challenges. To counteract these difficulties, he suggested using stiff blades, multiple threaded pins to secure the cutting jigs, and computer navigation.

 

For More Information:

Chin PL, Yang KY, Yeo SJ, et al. Randomized controlled trial comparing radiographic total knee arthroplasty placement using computer navigation against conventional technique. J Arthroplasty. 2005;20(5):618-66.

Foo LSS, Lin CP, Yang K-Y, et al. RCT comparing radiological outcomes of conventional versus minimally invasive techniques for TKA. #138. Presented at the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons 73rd Annual Meeting. March 22-26, 2006. Chicago. Also presented at the 29th Annual Scientific Meeting of the Singapore Orthopaedic Association. Nov. 8-11, 2006. Singapore.


About the author

Dr Chin Pak Lin

Orthopaedic


Orthopedic Surgeon Specialist Singapore - Dr Chin Pak Lin
Passing On Knowledge 7 January 2020
Zumba Injuries and Prevention shared by Dr Chin Pak Lin
Zumba Injuries And Prevention 13 July 2015
Orthopedic Surgeon Specialist Singapore - Dr Chin Pak Lin
Future Forward Channel News Asia Interview On Orthopaedics 11 March 2015
Hip Replacement Singapore with Dr Chin Pak Lin
Hip Replacement Surgery With Swift Recovery | 置换髋关节 隔天能走路 1 December 2014
Robotic Knee Replacement Surgery by Dr Chin Pak Lin
Surgical Help From Robots For Knee Replacement (AsiaOne YourHealth) 23 November 2014

Doctor’s News


Doctor’s Medical Insights

New robot helps to cut errors in knee surgery 28 September 2024
Let’s Talk About Knee Pain Problems & Total Knee Replacement 24 September 2024
Introduction To Hip Surgery 23 September 2024
Rehabilitation after Joint replacement surgery 13 September 2024
Orthopedic Surgeon Specialist Singapore - Dr Chin Pak Lin
Minimally Invasive Joint Replacement Surgery 13 September 2024
Let Our Doctors Help You Find a Solution
for Your Medical Conditions Today.
Get In Touch with

Our Specialists

Make an Appointment

Book Now

Let Our Doctors Help You Find a Solution for Your Medical Conditions Today.
Get In Touch with

Our Specialists

Make an Appointment

Book Now

Let Our Doctors Help You Find a Solution for Your Medical Conditions Today.
Get In Touch with

Our Specialists


Make an Appointment

Book Now

Asian Healthcare Specialists is a multi-disciplinary medical services group that provides an extended range of medical services.
Our Services
> Anaesthesia
> Dermatology
> ENT
> Family medicine
> Gastroenterology
> Ophthalmology
> Orthopaedic
> Urology
Our Services
> Anaesthesia
> Dermatology
> ENT
> Family medicine
> Gastroenterology
> Ophthalmology
> Orthopaedic
> Urology
Recent Blog
Dr Yue Talks About Back Pain on Channel 8 Let’s Talk About Health 医聊大小事 16 February 2024
Continuing To Serve 25 January 2020
Passing On Knowledge 7 January 2020
Dr Yue Talks About Scoliosis In Children On CNA938 Health Matters 26 July 2019
Symposium Speaker And Discussant At APSS-APPOS 2019 7 May 2019
Contact Us

Contact our Specialists

enquiry@asianhealthcare.com.sg

Visit our Clinics

Copyright © 2024 Asian Healthcare Specialists. All Rights Reserved | PDPA Policy

  • Home
  • Our Services
    • Dermatology
    • ENT
    • Gastroenterology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Orthopaedic
    • Urology
    • Family Medicine
    • Anaesthesia
  • About Us
    • Our Specialists
    • Careers
  • Our Clinics
  • Newsroom
  • Medical Insights
  • Contact Us
    • Medical Enquiry
    • Corporate Enquiry
    • Book an Appointment
    • Consult Our Specialists